The Indianapolis Colts rejected the New York Giants' offer of second- and fifth-round draft picks for running back Jonathan Taylor, reports said Sunday, November 8. New York subsequently withdrew the proposal, Fox Sports reporter Jay Glazer reported, according to Pro Football Rumors.
The Giants made the proposal a couple of weeks earlier, Glazer reported, according to NBC Sports' Pro Football Talk. The withdrawal takes that package off the table as Indianapolis weighs whether to keep its established starter or exchange him for draft capital.
Giants Step Back Over the Price
The compensation had become a sticking point for New York. The Giants' interest cooled because of the acquisition cost, NFL reporter Josina Anderson reported, according to NFL Trade Rumors. The fifth-round selection was a 2028 pick, Glazer reported, according to NFL Trade Rumors.
New York was the only team to offer a second-round selection plus additional compensation, NFL insider Jordan Schultz reported, according to Big Blue View. That gives the withdrawn package significance beyond one unsuccessful negotiation. On that account, Indianapolis turned down an offer with a combination of draft assets that other bidders had not matched. The Giants' retreat therefore narrows the reported market at that price, leaving the Colts to weigh the value of keeping Taylor against the compensation another club might offer before the deadline.
The negotiations concern a player with contractual control beyond this season. Taylor was under contract through 2028, NFL.com reported October 31. Denver, Green Bay, Minnesota, New York and Seattle were among the interested clubs as of October 31, according to NFL.com.
That contract horizon gives the proposed deal stakes beyond the remainder of 2026: Indianapolis would be surrendering multiple seasons of control, while an acquiring team would be pursuing more than a short-term addition.
Jonathan Taylor's Extension Adds Context
The Colts announced Taylor's extension August 6, just three months before Sunday's reporting. It was his second extension with Indianapolis, following the agreement he signed in October 2023.
Taylor said October 29 that he had not requested a trade, according to the Colts' account of his comments. Taylor is also a three-time Colts captain, according to the team. He earned Pro Bowl selections in 2021, 2024 and 2025.
Two Colts teammates were approaching unrestricted free agency after the 2026 season, unlike Taylor, the team said October 29.
Taylor's production also explains the stakes for Indianapolis' offense. Through eight games this season, he had 148 carries for 610 yards and eight rushing touchdowns, along with 21 receptions for 202 yards, according to NFL Trade Rumors.
Colts Explained Taylor's Reduced Workload
Taylor's reduced workload against Jacksonville reflected the game situation, the Colts said November 5. He carried eight times for 23 yards in the previous week's 42-7 loss. Indianapolis trailed 28-0 at halftime and removed starters in the fourth quarter; the team said trade speculation had not driven his reduced usage.
That explanation separates his limited carries from the negotiations drawing attention across NFL coverage.
On November 5, Taylor was preparing for Sunday's home game against Dallas at Lucas Oil Stadium, according to the Colts. The next deadline for a trade is Tuesday, November 10, at 4 p.m. Eastern.
Photo: Jonathan Taylor 2019 by Bely Medved (CC BY-SA 2.0), via Wikimedia Commons.
Discussion
Join the discussion
Useful notes, corrections, and field experience belong here. Keep replies specific and constructive.